Do I need a QRNG? An honest answer
Often, no. A correctly seeded CSPRNG on a platform with a sound entropy source is adequate for most applications. A dedicated quantum entropy source earns its place when keys are long-lived, when you must produce evidence rather than assurances, when devices ship in volume without an operator, or when a regulator asks where randomness comes from.
Sometimes the answer is no, and that is the answer this page will give you when it applies.
When you probably do not need one
- Your application runs on general-purpose servers, uses a maintained TLS library, and generates session keys that live for minutes.
- Your platform exposes a well-regarded entropy source and you have no requirement to evidence it beyond that.
- Your threat model is a remote attacker with no physical access and no interest in keys years from now.
- You are generating large volumes of random data for something other than cryptography.
In these cases the marginal security gain is small, and effort spent on key management, rotation and dependency hygiene will buy more than a hardware entropy source will.
When the answer changes
- Long-lived keys. A CA root, a firmware signing key, a device identity fused at manufacture. Compromise is discovered years later and is unrecoverable.
- Evidence requirements. An evaluation, an audit or a customer security review that asks not whether you use good randomness but what evidence supports it. Assurances do not survive that conversation; evidence does.
- Volume manufacturing. Every device needs its own unpredictable secret, generated at first boot, with no operator and often no network. This is where entropy failures have historically produced duplicate keys across entire product lines.
- Regulatory drivers. Frameworks that ask about the cryptographic supply chain increasingly reach the entropy source, and answering requires a source you can describe.
The question underneath
All four cases are the same question: can you produce evidence about your randomness, or only assurance? If assurance is sufficient for your situation, a good CSPRNG is a good answer. If it is not, the gap is not fixed by better software.
If you have concluded you need one, the buyer's guide is the next page. If you are not sure, assess what you have now before adding anything.